CHAN YAT MAN V. TUNG PO (H. K.) TECHNOLOGY ENTERPRISE LTD

[2025] HKCA 423 Court of Appeal 12 May 2025 • CACV414/2022 • 27 min read

5 cases cited (0 HK, 5 foreign)

Outcome

Appeal dismissed

we dismissed the appeal.

Source: [2025] HKCA 423, Court of Appeal, decided 12 May 2025. Read directly from the judgment.

Practice Areas

Loans & Debt Recovery Company & Shareholder Disputes

Judges (3)

Cheung Coram Chu Coram G Lam Coram

Counsel (5)

Eric Cheung & Lau Firm W K To & Co Firm Martin Wong Counsel Defendant Matthew Ho Counsel Plaintiff Patrick Lau Counsel Defendant

Parties (2)

Tung Po (H. K.) Technology Enterprise Limited Defendant Chan Yat Man Plaintiff

Case Significance

CHAN YAT MAN V. TUNG PO (H. K.) TECHNOLOGY ENTERPRISE LTD [2025] HKCA 423 is a Court of Appeal decision dated 12 May 2025 spanning the loans and debt recovery and company and shareholder disputes areas, engaging section 49(2) of the Evidence Ordinance. The Court of Appeal held: "we dismissed the appeal." The judgment cited HUNG WAI KUEN AND OTHERS V. CHENG SHUN PING [2024] HKCA 799 and CHEN HONGQING V. ASIA CEMENT CORPORATION [2024] HKCA 463, together with English authority including [2022] EWCA Civ 464.

Summary

Chan Yat Man brought a civil claim against Tung Po (H.K.) Technology Enterprise Limited. The Court of Appeal considered the appeal arising from the commercial dispute.

What did the Court of Appeal decide in CHAN YAT MAN V. TUNG PO (H. K.) TECHNOLOGY ENTERPRISE LTD [2025] HKCA 423?

The Court of Appeal held: "we dismissed the appeal," in a decision dated 12 May 2025 spanning loans and debt recovery and company and shareholder disputes, engaging section 49(2) of the Evidence Ordinance.

What earlier decisions did the Court of Appeal cite in CHAN YAT MAN V. TUNG PO (H. K.) TECHNOLOGY ENTERPRISE LTD [2025] HKCA 423?

The judgment cited HUNG WAI KUEN AND OTHERS V. CHENG SHUN PING [2024] HKCA 799 and CHEN HONGQING V. ASIA CEMENT CORPORATION [2024] HKCA 463, together with the English authority [2022] EWCA Civ 464.