[2026] HKCA 214, COMPETITION COMMISSION V. ATAL BUILDING SERVICES ENGINEERING LTD AND OTHERS (and 1 other) - Judgment, Outcome & Holding

Judges (2)

Counsel (5)

Baker & McKenzie Firm Dentons Hong Kong LLP Firm Jonathan Ng Counsel Respondent Leticia Tang Counsel Applicant Stephen Crosswell Counsel Respondent

Parties (6)

ATAL Building Services Engineering Limited Respondent Competition Commission Applicant Johnson Controls Hong Kong Limited Respondent Johnson Controls International PLC Respondent York International (Northern Asia) Limited Respondent Lee Yui Ming Respondent

Summary

The Competition Commission appealed in proceedings against Atal Building Services Engineering Ltd and others in a bid-rigging case — one of the first contested competition enforcement actions in Hong Kong. The case concerned anti-competitive conduct in the building services industry. The Court of Appeal heard the consolidated appeals with judgment delivered on 12 February 2026.