[2025] HKCA 587, CHEN YUNG NGAI KENNETH AND ANOTHER V. HO YUK WAH DAVID AND OTHERS - Judgment, Outcome & Holding

Judges (2)

Counsel (4)

Lee, Wong & Lam Firm Rita Law & Co Firm Fergus Chan Counsel Defendant Joseph Wong Counsel Plaintiff

Parties (12)

Asia-Pac Group Investments Limited Defendant Asia-Pac Infrastructure Development Limited Defendant Asia-Pac Pacific Region Properties (Holdings) Limited Defendant CHEN YUNG NGAI KENNETH and CHAN MEI MEI (trustees-in-bankruptcy of the 1st Defendant), substituted as the Plaintiffs for IP PUI LAM ARTHUR and IP PUI SUM (former trustees-in-bankruptcy of the 1st Defendant) by Order of Master Chow dated 16 January 2020 Plaintiff Gladius Limited Defendant Grand Asia Capital Services Limited Defendant Ho Yuk Wah David (a bankrupt) Defendant King Ocean Development Inc Defendant Ontrade Properties Limited Defendant Pacific Shine Limited Defendant Sparkle Lanes Limited Defendant Tsun King Group Limited Defendant

Summary

Bankruptcy-related dispute between trustees-in-bankruptcy Chen Yung Ngai Kenneth and Chan Mei Mei (substituted plaintiffs) against Ho Yuk Wah David (a bankrupt) and his associated companies including Gladius Limited and Ontrade Properties Limited. The Court of Appeal considered a leave application relating to costs orders. The application was determined on written submissions.